Comparison

Concentric vs Double Offset vs Triple Offset Butterfly Valves: What Changes and When Each Is Used

By · · 4 min read

Three side sections of a butterfly valve: concentric with the stem through the disc and a rubber seat, double offset with the stem behind the seat and below centre, and triple offset with a cone-shaped metal seat, with typical services and pressure classes below each
Diagram: Engine-X
In short

Butterfly valves come in three designs that differ only in where the stem sits behind the seat. How concentric, double offset and triple offset valves seal, what pressures and temperatures each handles, and how API 609 groups them.

Key takeaways
Contents
  1. What is an "offset" in a butterfly valve?
  2. Concentric (zero offset): the everyday water valve
  3. Double offset: the disc cams away from the seat
  4. Triple offset: metal to metal with no rubbing
  5. Concentric vs double vs triple offset compared
  6. How do you choose between them?
  7. The engineering takeaway

Concentric, double offset and triple offset butterfly valves differ in where the stem sits. A concentric valve has the stem through the disc centre and a rubber seat, for water and low pressure. A double offset moves the stem behind the seat and off centre for higher pressure. A triple offset adds a cone-shaped metal seat for steam and hydrocarbons.

The new Engine-X butterfly valve 3D model is the first kind, a 6-inch concentric lug valve with a worm gear operator, and the butterfly valve guide explains how its disc, seat and gearbox work.

What is an "offset" in a butterfly valve?

An offset is a deliberate shift of the stem, or of the seat, away from the simple centred layout. In a concentric valve the stem runs through the centre of the disc and the bore, so the disc edge stays pressed into the seat as it turns (Project Materials).

Each offset moves the geometry so that the disc swings away from the seat sooner and rubs it less.

API 609, the butterfly valve standard, groups them in two categories (Project Materials):

  1. Category A: concentric, soft-seated valves for lower-pressure, lower-temperature service.
  2. Category B: double and triple offset valves for higher pressure service.

Concentric (zero offset): the everyday water valve

In a concentric valve the disc edge rubs the rubber seat through the whole stroke, so the seat is the part that wears fastest. Seats are elastomers such as EPDM, NBR or Viton, and the design is used for water, HVAC, fire protection and water treatment, up to about Class 150 and 120 °C (Project Materials).

Its strengths are size, cost and tight shut-off at low pressure. A 6-inch lug valve is only 56 mm face to face and is rated 200 psig both ways (Titan FCI). Keystone rates its resilient seat for drop-tight shut-off at the full 10 bar rating and gives the 6-inch size a flow of Cv 2790 fully open (Keystone).

Double offset: the disc cams away from the seat

A double offset valve has two offsets: the stem sits behind the plane of the seat, and it also sits off the pipe centre line. Together they act like a cam, lifting the disc off the seat early in opening and giving a wiping seal on closing (Project Materials).

Less rubbing means the seat lasts longer and can be either resilient or metal. Double offset valves suit cooling water, process water and moderate-pressure process duty from Class 150 to 300, at up to about 250 °C with resilient seats or 400 °C with metal seats (Project Materials).

Triple offset: metal to metal with no rubbing

The triple offset keeps both stem offsets and adds a third: the seating surface is a cone at an angle instead of a flat ring. The disc then touches the seat only at the very end of closing, so there is no rubbing during most of the stroke (Project Materials).

That allows metal seats, in materials such as Stellite, Inconel or stainless steel, with bubble-tight Class VI shut-off. Triple offset valves are used for hydrocarbons, steam and high-temperature process, from Class 150 to 900 and in some designs up to 1500, with metal seats rated to about 815 °C (Project Materials).

Concentric vs double vs triple offset compared

Concentric Double offset Triple offset
Stem position Through the disc centre Behind the seat and off centre Behind and off centre
Seat Rubber (EPDM, NBR, Viton) Rubber or metal Metal, cone shaped
Seat contact Rubs the whole stroke Lifts off early Touches only at closing
Pressure class Up to Class 150 Class 150 to 300 Class 150 to 900+
Temperature About 120 °C About 250 °C soft, 400 °C metal About 815 °C
Typical service Water, HVAC, fire Process and cooling water Steam, hydrocarbons
API 609 Category A Category B Category B

Figures from Project Materials, which also warns that a concentric rubber-seated valve should not be used in hydrocarbon service above 200 °C, because the elastomer degrades.

How do you choose between them?

Start from the fluid, pressure and temperature, then choose the cheapest design that covers them. Clean water at low pressure is concentric territory.

Higher pressure, or a need for longer seat life, moves you to double offset. Hydrocarbons, steam, high temperature or a need for metal-to-metal bubble-tight shut-off call for triple offset. Above roughly 8 to 10 inches, any of them is usually fitted with a worm gearbox or an actuator rather than a lever (Project Materials).

For a valve that is fully open or fully shut and must leave a clear bore, compare the butterfly valve with the gate valve: far longer and slower to operate, but with nothing in the flow when open.

The engineering takeaway

Every butterfly valve is the same idea, a disc turned a quarter turn, but where the stem sits decides how the disc meets its seat. Concentric valves rub a rubber seat and serve water; each offset lifts the disc away sooner, until the triple offset closes metal on metal with no rubbing at all.

TL;DR A concentric butterfly valve has the stem through the middle of the disc and a rubber seat for water and low pressure; a double offset moves the stem behind and off centre so the disc lifts away for higher pressure; a triple offset adds a cone-shaped metal seat for steam, hydrocarbons and high temperature.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a double offset and a triple offset butterfly valve?

Both have the stem behind the seat and off the pipe centre line. A triple offset adds a third offset: the seat is a cone at an angle, so the metal disc touches the metal seat only in the last moment of closing, with no rubbing during the stroke.

What does API 609 Category A mean?

It is the API 609 group for concentric, soft-seated butterfly valves used in lower-pressure, lower-temperature service. Category B covers the double and triple offset designs.

Can a concentric butterfly valve be used for steam or hydrocarbons?

Not at high temperature. Its elastomer seat degrades, and a concentric resilient-seated valve should not be used in hydrocarbon service above about 200 °C; triple offset metal-seated valves are made for that duty.

Which butterfly valve wears its seat fastest?

The concentric valve, because its disc edge rubs the rubber seat through the whole stroke every time it opens and closes. Each added offset reduces that contact.

Sources
Butterfly Valve 3D model
Free 3D model · download

Butterfly Valve

NPS 6 lug butterfly valve, concentric and rubber seated, with a 24 : 1 worm gear operator: disc, stem, seat, gearbox and handwheel. Real scale, every part named. Download the whole machine as GLB or STL, grab any of its 21 parts as its own STL, or view it in AR on your phone.

Free for personal and educational use (CC BY-NC 4.0), credit Engine‑X.

LinkedInWhatsAppX
See the Butterfly Valve in 3D
Butterfly ValveNPS 6 lug butterfly valve, concentric and rubber seated, with a 24 : 1 worm gear operator: disc, stem, seat, gearbox and handwheel. TurbochargerExhaust-driven turbine spinning a compressor, with journal bearings and a wastegate. V-Belt Pulley DriveTwo pulleys and a V-belt reducing speed with true belt kinematics. Centrifugal PumpEnd-suction pump with a backward-curved impeller and volute casing. Helical Gear ReducerTwo-stage helical gearbox, 16 : 1, with meshing helical gears and tapered roller bearings. Marine Diesel EngineInline-6, 14 L marine diesel in the NT855 Big Cam style: pistons, camshaft, 24 valves, PT injectors, turbo and sea water cooling. Plate Heat ExchangerGasketed plate-and-frame exchanger, 41 plates, DN100, with hot and cold water in alternate channels. Reciprocating Air CompressorTwo-stage piston compressor, 12 bar, with reed valves, an intercooler, a V-belt drive and an air tank. Planetary GearboxSingle-stage planetary reducer, 5 : 1: sun, three planets, fixed ring gear and carrier output. Turbofan Jet EngineTwo-spool high-bypass turbofan in the CFM56-7B style: 61-inch fan, booster, 9-stage compressor, combustor and turbines. Gate ValveNPS 4 Class 150 OS&Y wedge gate valve: rising stem, bolted bonnet, graphite packing and handwheel. Car DifferentialRear-axle open differential, 41 : 11 = 3.73 : 1: ring and pinion, spider and side gears, axle shafts. Car Engine2.0 L inline-four petrol engine, DOHC 16-valve: crankshaft, pistons, chain-driven camshafts, valves, spark plugs and injectors. Induction Motor7.5 kW, 4-pole three-phase squirrel-cage motor, IEC 132M: stator windings, aluminium rotor cage, bearings and cooling fan. Manual Gearbox5-speed manual transaxle with VW 02T ratios: input and output shafts, five gear pairs, synchronisers, shift forks and final drive.

Explode, X‑ray and cut them open, free in your browser.

Need your machine in 3D?

Engine‑X builds interactive 3D websites for pumps, valves, gearboxes and other machines that buyers can rotate, explode and section, plus 3D explainers for colleges and trainers. Free quote within 24 hours, 3 rounds of revisions included.

Get a free quote → What's included

Mechanical engineer and designer from India. He has designed and drafted marine engineering projects in AutoCAD and SolidWorks, and works in ship repair and dry docking, with hands-on experience in piping, valves, fabrication and pressure testing. He builds Engine-X, a free interactive 3D atlas that shows how real machines work inside.

About · LinkedIn · Contact