Comparison

Open vs Limited-Slip vs Locking Differential: How Each One Splits the Power

By · · 4 min read

Diagram comparing four differentials on a car stuck with one wheel on ice — open, clutch-type limited-slip, gear-type Torsen and locker — with arrows showing how much torque reaches the wheel with grip in each case
Diagram: Engine-X
In short

Why one wheel spins when a car is stuck, and how limited-slip, Torsen-style gear, locking and spool differentials fix it. How each works inside and where each one belongs.

Key takeaways
Contents
  1. Why does one wheel spin when a car is stuck?
  2. How does a limited-slip differential work?
  3. What is torque bias ratio?
  4. Open, limited-slip, locker and spool compared
  5. Which differential should you choose?
  6. The engineering takeaway

An open differential always splits engine torque equally between the two wheels, which is why one wheel spins on ice and the car goes nowhere. Limited-slip differentials add friction to send more torque to the wheel with grip, and lockers join both axles so the wheels turn as one. Each type trades traction against smooth cornering.

You can watch the spider gears let the wheels run at different speeds in the new Engine-X car differential 3D model, and the car differential guide explains every part from the drive pinion to the axle flanges.

Why does one wheel spin when a car is stuck?

One wheel spins because an open differential always gives both wheels the same torque. The spider gears push equally on both side gears. If one wheel sits on ice, it can only take a tiny torque before it slips, and the wheel with grip gets exactly the same tiny torque.

The result is the classic "one-tyre fire": all the engine speed goes to the spinning wheel while the other sits still (Speedway Motors). The open diff is not broken; it is doing its job of letting the wheels turn at different speeds, which the outside wheel needs in every corner (EngineerFix).

How does a limited-slip differential work?

A limited-slip differential (LSD) acts like an open diff most of the time but resists one wheel spinning much faster than the other. It does that with friction, so the wheel with grip can be given more torque than the slipping wheel. There are two common mechanical kinds:

  1. Clutch-type (Positraction). Stacks of friction discs and steel plates sit between the side gears and the case, pre-loaded by springs. Under power, the side gears push outward and squeeze the clutches, tying the axles together harder the more torque goes in. A 1-way LSD locks only on acceleration, a 1.5-way adds some locking when slowing down, and a 2-way locks equally on both, which drifters like (Speedway Motors, Jalopnik). The clutches wear slowly and need gear oil with a friction modifier.
  2. Gear-type (Torsen, Eaton Truetrac). No clutches: helical or worm gears do the work. Torque on the helical teeth creates thrust that pushes the gears against the case walls, and that friction grows with torque (Torsen). Nothing wears out like a clutch, but if one wheel has zero grip it still gets no torque; a light touch of the brake can give the diff something to push against (Speedway Motors).

Viscous couplings, which thicken silicone fluid as the wheels slip, and electronic e-LSDs, which clamp clutches with an actuator under computer control, do the same job in other ways (Jalopnik).

What is torque bias ratio?

Torque bias ratio (TBR) is the number that rates a gear-type differential. It is the ratio of high-traction to low-traction torque the diff can hold before the two wheels start slipping relative to each other (Torsen). A higher TBR sends more of the torque to the wheel with grip and feels more aggressive.

For example, with a TBR of 3 : 1, if the slippery wheel can take 100 N·m, the wheel with grip can be given up to 300 N·m, so the axle delivers 400 N·m instead of the 200 N·m an open diff would allow.

Open, limited-slip, locker and spool compared

Type How it works Traction with one wheel on ice Cornering Best for
Open Spider gears, equal torque Lowest: both wheels get the slipping wheel's torque Smoothest Normal road cars
Clutch LSD Clutch packs and springs add friction Good Smooth, slight chatter possible Daily drivers, track, drifting (2-way)
Gear LSD (Torsen-style) Helical gear friction, set by TBR Good, but none if a wheel has zero grip Smooth, no clutches to wear Daily drivers, road racing
Automatic locker Locks the axles when torque is applied Full: both wheels turn together Clunks and jolts, pushes wide Off-road, street-strip
Selectable locker Air or electric, switched on by the driver Full when locked Open when unlocked Off-road 4×4
Spool Axles permanently joined Full Tyres scrub and chirp in turns Drag racing, rock crawling

Sources: Speedway Motors, Jalopnik, Torsen.

Which differential should you choose?

Choose by where the car spends its time. For ordinary road driving an open differential, backed by the car's traction control, is fine.

For spirited road and track driving a limited-slip diff gives traction out of corners without hurting turn-in. For rock crawling and serious off-road work a selectable locker gives full traction only when it is switched on, and spools belong on drag strips and crawlers, not daily roads.

Whatever the type, the ring and pinion in front of it decide the overall ratio and the torque multiplication, the same way the gear stages do in an industrial reducer; see helical vs worm gear reducers and the post on gear types: spur, helical, bevel and worm.

The engineering takeaway

An open differential is a torque splitter: equal torque, free speeds, so the weakest wheel sets the limit. Limited-slip diffs break that rule with friction, from clutches or from helical gear thrust, and lockers break it completely by forcing equal speeds. More locking means more traction and less smooth turning, so the right differential is the one that matches the road the car actually drives on.

TL;DR An open differential always splits torque equally, so the wheel with least grip sets the limit. A limited-slip differential adds friction (clutches or gears) to send more torque to the wheel with grip, and a locker ties both axles together so they turn as one.

Frequently asked questions

Why does one wheel spin when a car is stuck?

An open differential always gives both wheels the same torque. If one wheel is on ice it can only take a tiny torque before it spins, so the wheel with grip gets that same tiny torque and the car does not move.

What is the difference between a limited-slip and a locking differential?

A limited-slip differential still lets the wheels turn at different speeds but uses friction to send more torque to the wheel with grip. A locking differential joins the two axles so both wheels turn at exactly the same speed when it is locked.

What is torque bias ratio?

Torque bias ratio is how much more torque a gear-type differential can send to the wheel with more grip than to the wheel with less before the wheels start to slip relative to each other. A higher ratio means more aggressive traction.

Can you drive a locked differential on the road?

Automatic lockers are streetable but can clunk, jolt and push the car wide in corners, and selectable lockers are meant to be switched on only off-road. A spool, which is always locked, scrubs and chirps the tyres in every turn.

Sources
Car Differential 3D model
Free 3D model · download

Car Differential

Rear-axle open differential, 41 : 11 = 3.73 : 1: ring and pinion, spider and side gears, axle shafts. Real scale, every part named. Download the whole machine as GLB or STL, grab any of its 34 parts as its own STL, or view it in AR on your phone.

Free for personal and educational use (CC BY-NC 4.0), credit Engine‑X.

LinkedInWhatsAppX
See the Car Differential in 3D
Car DifferentialRear-axle open differential, 41 : 11 = 3.73 : 1: ring and pinion, spider and side gears, axle shafts. TurbochargerExhaust-driven turbine spinning a compressor, with journal bearings and a wastegate. V-Belt Pulley DriveTwo pulleys and a V-belt reducing speed with true belt kinematics. Centrifugal PumpEnd-suction pump with a backward-curved impeller and volute casing. Helical Gear ReducerTwo-stage helical gearbox, 16 : 1, with meshing helical gears and tapered roller bearings. Marine Diesel EngineInline-6, 14 L marine diesel in the NT855 Big Cam style: pistons, camshaft, 24 valves, PT injectors, turbo and sea water cooling. Plate Heat ExchangerGasketed plate-and-frame exchanger, 41 plates, DN100, with hot and cold water in alternate channels. Reciprocating Air CompressorTwo-stage piston compressor, 12 bar, with reed valves, an intercooler, a V-belt drive and an air tank. Planetary GearboxSingle-stage planetary reducer, 5 : 1: sun, three planets, fixed ring gear and carrier output. Turbofan Jet EngineTwo-spool high-bypass turbofan in the CFM56-7B style: 61-inch fan, booster, 9-stage compressor, combustor and turbines. Gate ValveNPS 4 Class 150 OS&Y wedge gate valve: rising stem, bolted bonnet, graphite packing and handwheel. Car Engine2.0 L inline-four petrol engine, DOHC 16-valve: crankshaft, pistons, chain-driven camshafts, valves, spark plugs and injectors. Induction Motor7.5 kW, 4-pole three-phase squirrel-cage motor, IEC 132M: stator windings, aluminium rotor cage, bearings and cooling fan. Manual Gearbox5-speed manual transaxle with VW 02T ratios: input and output shafts, five gear pairs, synchronisers, shift forks and final drive. Butterfly ValveNPS 6 lug butterfly valve, concentric and rubber seated, with a 24 : 1 worm gear operator: disc, stem, seat, gearbox and handwheel.

Explode, X‑ray and cut them open, free in your browser.

Need your machine in 3D?

Engine‑X builds interactive 3D websites for pumps, valves, gearboxes and other machines that buyers can rotate, explode and section, plus 3D explainers for colleges and trainers. Free quote within 24 hours, 3 rounds of revisions included.

Get a free quote → What's included

Mechanical engineer and designer from India. He has designed and drafted marine engineering projects in AutoCAD and SolidWorks, and works in ship repair and dry docking, with hands-on experience in piping, valves, fabrication and pressure testing. He builds Engine-X, a free interactive 3D atlas that shows how real machines work inside.

About · LinkedIn · Contact